The case against "new year, new you”


There's a strange paradox about January.

Every ad, every influencer, every gym promo tells us this is the time to sprint. New goals. New habits. New you. Attack the year before it attacks you.

But look outside. At least in the northern hemisphere, it's the middle of winter. The days are short. The light is thin. Every living thing is conserving energy.

Except us. We're supposed to be "hitting the ground running."

See the problem?

The "new year, new me" energy isn't motivation. It's pressure dressed up as inspiration. And for high achievers, it's particularly dangerous. Because we don't need more reasons to push harder. We need permission to pause.

Here's what I've noticed about January launches:

The goals set in the first week are usually the goals we think we should have. The ones that sound impressive. The ones that prove we're not slowing down.

The goals that actually matter? Those tend to emerge later. After we've had time to sit with what we really want. After the noise of everyone else's resolutions fades.

There's a reason farmers don't plant in January. The soil isn't ready. Neither are we. Because we haven't had time to recover from the year that just ended.

What if this month wasn't for launching?

What if it was for listening?

Listening to what last year actually taught us. Listening to what our bodies need after a year of pushing. Listening to the quiet voice that knows what we want. The one that gets drowned out by productivity culture.

Spring will come. The energy to build will return. And when it does, we'll be ready. Not because we forced it, but because we gave ourselves the winter we actually needed.

This week, try this:

Instead of setting a new goal, ask: what am I still recovering from? What haven't I processed yet? That's not procrastination. That's preparation.

Second Summit Brief by Clif Mathews

Second Summit Brief is a weekly letter for high-achieving leaders who’ve realized the summit they climbed isn’t the one they want to stay on. Each edition blends reflection and strategy to help you see the patterns keeping you stuck and find the clarity, courage, and integration that define your own second summit.

Read more from Second Summit Brief by Clif Mathews

There's a question most high achievers avoid at all costs: Who are you without the title? Not what you do. Not what you've built. Not what's on your LinkedIn. You. The person underneath the credentials. If that question makes you uncomfortable, you're not alone. For most of us, identity and achievement have been fused together for so long that we can't see where one ends and the other begins. We became the role. The performer. The one who delivers. And it worked. That identity got us...

There's a version of the Success Trap that doesn't look like burnout or emptiness. It looks like things just...not working the way they used to. The formula that always delivered starts to sputter. The wins get harder. The confidence that came from a long track record starts to crack. Not catastrophically. Not publicly. But enough that you notice. I was talking with Kathy Wu Brady recently (follow her on LinkedIn), and we stumbled onto something that stopped us both mid-conversation. We'd...

You're allowed to outgrow a place that once felt right. Even if everyone says you're thriving. This is one of the hardest forms of misalignment to recognize. There's no obvious villain. No toxic boss, no unreasonable workload, no clear reason to leave. You deliver great results. You get along with the people around you. You've built your success over years. And still...something feels off. When something's obviously wrong, it's clear you need to make a change. But it's much harder to see...