Becoming a senior leader was the easy part


Hey Reader,

You've made it.

The senior role you’ve worked toward for years is finally yours. Everyone rushes over to congratulate you. People you’ve known for years tell you they always knew you could do it. It feels like everything you imagined it would.

And then the applause fades, and the work begins.

You sit through your first few meetings, and something doesn't feel quite right. No one's being hostile or even particularly difficult. But as the days go by, you start to notice a few things. One colleague tells you, "This is how we did things before. It's worked well, so we figured it would stay the same." Someone else mentions that your style is a little different from your predecessor's. The team genuinely wants you to succeed. But without realizing it, they keep pulling you back toward the way things were done before.

You start to notice it everywhere. In the systems you inherited. In the expectations around how decisions get made. In the conversations that happen (and the ones that don't). The role is yours on paper. But some days, it can feel like your predecessor is still in the room.

One executive I worked with experienced this in a pretty extreme way. After his company split in two, he became CEO of the original company. His predecessor, who was also his mentor, left to lead the new one. From the outside, it looked like a clean transition. It wasn't.

Almost immediately, the former CEO started weighing in on how his successor should run the company. How decisions should be made. What the priorities should be. What the culture should look like.

Because of their history, the new CEO found it hard to draw a line. He worried that pushing back would seem ungrateful. The team had also spent years working a certain way, and they were comfortable with it. So even though he was now the CEO, he felt pressure to lead the same way his predecessor had.

Eventually, it came to a head in a board meeting. Not the setting either of them would have chosen. The former CEO made it clear that he thought his way was still the right way. But the new CEO had reached a point where he couldn't keep trying to lead like the person who came before him.

The board backed him. They had appointed him to lead the company, and they didn't expect him to do it exactly as his predecessor had.

Eventually, the former CEO moved on, and the new CEO had the space to lead in his own way. He started visiting different locations and talking to employees at every level. He listened to what mattered to them and made those things a priority. His approach was very different from his predecessor's, and it worked. He knew what he needed to do and stuck with it, even when it took longer than he'd hoped.

Most leaders stepping into a new role will never have a board meeting like that. But what was happening underneath it is much more common.

You come into a role knowing the kind of leader you want to be. At the same time, you're surrounded by people who already have an idea of how someone in your position is supposed to lead.

When I'm coaching new execs, we don't start with grand announcements or plans to change the whole organization. That can come later, if it's actually what they want to do. We start with a much simpler question: What do you want to do differently, and why?

Getting clear on that matters. Because when people question your decisions or push you toward the way things used to be done, you need to know why you're choosing a different path.

It also helps to be clear about what you don't want to change. Not everything your predecessor built needs to go. There may be plenty that works and is worth keeping. Being open about that can make it easier for people to understand where you're going and why.

The transition will still be uncomfortable at times. And some of the changes you want to make will take longer than you'd like. But every time you make a decision that reflects how you want to lead, you make the role a little more your own. Eventually, what once felt new simply becomes the way things are done.

What would you do differently if no one was comparing you to who came before? Hit reply. I'd like to hear about it.

From one human to another,

There are five traps that keep leaders stuck. Which one is driving you?

1

​The Speed Trap​

"If I slow down, I fall behind."

2

​The Identity Trap​

"I am this role."

3

​The Title Trap​

"I can't step down from this level."

4

​The Alignment Trap​

"I'm excellent at something I don't believe in."

5

​The Metrics Trap​

"If I can't measure it, it doesn't count."

Click the statement that feels most true. Each one takes you to a short guide to help you understand the trap and what to do about it.

Not sure? Take the ​quiz​ to find out which one fits you.

The human side of leadership is something I've built my keynote around. If that's a conversation you'd like to bring to your organization, you can find out more by clicking the banner below.

600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246
​Unsubscribe · Pre​ferences​

A Normal Tuesday by Clif Mathews

You built everything you were supposed to build. And you're questioning everything. Quietly. It's not burnout. It's not weakness. It's the slow realization that somewhere along the way, you stopped living your life and started managing it. You're not alone in this. I spent 25 years chasing achievement before I saw it clearly. Every Tuesday, I write about what I found. The patterns. The permission to want something different. The occasional uncomfortable truth. No optimization hacks. No hustle. Just honest exploration from someone a few steps ahead on the same path.

Read more from A Normal Tuesday by Clif Mathews

Hey Reader, If you’re like me, you’ve spent a long time building the career you have today. Over the years, we’ve taken on bigger roles, more responsibility, and…more pressure. We’ve built a reputation for being the leader who can handle difficult problems, and we have the title to prove it. That focus on title carries into almost every social setting. When someone asks what we do, we know what to say. Our titles give them most of the answer. We don’t have to explain the 20 or 30 years of...

Hey Reader, There’s a decision you’ve been meaning to make. Perhaps it’s been sitting with you for months. Maybe longer. You know you need to make it. And you’ve already thought through every angle imaginable. But every time you get close to making a choice, there’s just one more thing you’d like to know first. One more variable you’d like to resolve. One more reason to wait a little longer. But at work, you could probably make three key decisions before lunch. There’s a huge gap in how...

Hey Reader, In my organization, there was this one partner who had become almost infamous. I didn’t work with him closely, but most of us knew one thing about him: he proudly said he was going to retire at 50, years before partners typically retired. Nobody believed him. From the outside, nothing about his situation suggested he should want to leave. He was highly respected, seated at the top of the organization, and his work was excellent. He had everything that most of us work hard for. No...